Discussion
Topics
Last Day
Last Week
Tree View

Documentation
Getting Started
FAQ
Formatting
Troubleshooting
Program Credits

Utilities
New Messages
Keyword Search
Contact
User Profile
Administration

 
Are the measures appropriate for addressing the research question?

intro.psych (Psyco 105) Discussion: Group 1 Discussion Group: Reading the Research - Social Development: Are the measures appropriate for addressing the research question?
By Jep on Sunday, October 11, 1998 - 05:08 pm:

I can't see why these aren't appropriate. If they work that is great. When I was in grade 6 if an adult, male or female, would have asked me if and who I was "dating" I would not have answered, maybe not honestly anyways. I think that the answers may vary depending on who is asking the questions. Also if you ask who they have had as "girlfriends" and "boyfriends" in the past that may not be a very good evaluation of what is truly going on. Because in those grades they go out for like a lunch hour, or maybe a couple of days. I think that asking both who have they "dated" as well as who would the "date" would help with a better estimation of what is really going on in their minds.


By Mike on Monday, October 12, 1998 - 02:46 pm:

I also agree that truth is a factor in the responses. Although the researchers said they were only "curious" and told the students there is no right or wrong answers, the younger subjects still probably tried to please the researchers by telling them what they thought was 'right'. I agree that a written questionnaire would have certainly reduced any fear the subjects were feeling. I also agree with Jep that these kids certainly have different ideas of what dating someone is in comparison to adults.


By Ivanka on Tuesday, October 13, 1998 - 10:00 pm:

Copied from "is the research design appropriate"

Considering that the research subjects were all adolescents and given what we know about human development at this age, it might have been more
appropriate if the questionnaire was not given verbally. This is because people at the subject's age are very self-conscious and have a tendency to
want to conform more than an adultmight. Therefore, with a verbal questionnaire, they might simply answer how they think the adult who was
questioning them might want them to answer. Adults are seen as an authority for young people and a student might not feel as comfortable telling an adult that he/she is attracted to very young or very old people. A student might feel more comfortable writing this information down on a piece of paper. Since this questionnaire was done verbally, I think it was good to have a person of the same sex asking the questions. A student might feel intimidated by someone of the opposite sex. I think the questions were appropriate and it is imoportant that they stated that money and parental permission were not an issue. that way, they are getting a more precise response without personal circumstance complicating the issue.


By Ivanka on Tuesday, October 13, 1998 - 10:18 pm:

SUMMARY - Self-report was probably the best way to gather this type of information. Perhaps a written questionaire would have given more accurate information than having the adolescents interviewed by adults who tend to intimidate younger people and may cause them to answer according to what they thought the adult might like to hear. Considering that it was a verbal interview, it was probably a good idea to have someone of the same sex asking the questions so the level of embarassment was reduced and answers could be given more freely. The answers may vary depending on how the question is worded as well. It might have been useful to ask who they have dated in the past in addition to who they would and are now dating. This type of report may not give a completely accurate description of what is going on in the lives of youth because their definition of dating may be different than an adult definition. Or perhaps it is because even though it is different, it is their version of the adult ritual.


Add a Message


This is a private posting area. A valid username and password combination is required to post messages to this discussion.
Username:  
Password:
Post as "Anonymous"